The Negative Reviews

Because it got a great 4.5 out of 5 star rating consensus in Amazon from reviewers, you will be sure that this is a truly incredible product. However, a few inconsistencies here and there prevent it from being the perfect cargo box that you’ll own. First of all, because of its size, you won’t be able to get it up on the roof of your vehicle all by yourself. Of course, you have to check on the compatibility of the cargo box with your car, so ask your retailer about the different sizes that it comes in with.

After installing this Thule Cargo Box, you will notice that your miles per gallon (mpg) of gas used will drop by a small one or two (again, depending on the vehicle), which isn’t that much at all. Using it will also produce some noticeable wind noise.

Reviewers also say that this thule cargo box is quite expensive compared to other brands.

The Positive Reviews

While they say that it is quite expensive, you truly get what you pay for plus more. Reviewers say that the Thule Ascent 1700 Cargo Box is very lightweight. This will most definitely help in the installation process.

Speaking of installations, reviewers commented that it was relatively easy, provided that you follow the instructions. You just get it on your cross bars or roof rack, place it as far back on the roof and tighten the knobs. The customers added that it takes less than ten minutes for two people to put it on.

This car top carrier can also hold a serious load of stuff. If you’re taking a long trip, this would be the best cargo box to use. It also has virtually zero rumble or vibration at high speeds – just the aforementioned wind noise, which is very understandable and tolerable. Reviewers also loved the fact that it comes with openings on either side. This means that you can stop the car for a while and get some things that you need from the box.

Buy From Amazon

Thule Cargo Box Conclusion

Reviewers really loved this Thule Cargo Box Ascent 1700. This is thanks to its aerodynamic design, easy installation, huge space for your stuff and convenient side openings. While it may have some minor issues, you will soon forget them when you have the comfort and peace of mind that the box delivers. The price is also considered an investment, as you will never want another cargo box for your car again.

Home | Hard Top Carriers

We found amazon.com to have the best prices and shipping policies on all Cargo Carriers including the Thule Excursion. To find out more Click Here.

Highland 10391 Soft Car Top Carrier Features:

• Made from durable, leak proof coated vinyl material
• Mounts to any roof rack for easy accessibility
• Adds over 15 cubic feet of storage for extra needed cargo
• It includes mounting hardware for installation
• Measures 38 inch wide, 38 inch length and 15 inches tall
• Weighs only 6 pounds

Highland 10391 Soft Car Top Carrier Reviews:

Most consumers that bought the Highland 10391 Kar Pak Rainproof Soft Car Top Carrier were easily impressed with the thick vinyl material that it is made of an excellent quality. They found that it was easily adaptable to any extreme weather conditions including snow, rain and hail.  Its compact size and durability were remarked upon by dozens of happy customers. One buyer even commented on their 6000 mile trip across the country it made it through rain, hail, high winds, and punishing sun and the carrier still did not leak or tear.

Large families found this Car Top Carrier perfect to fit the extra baby gear and strollers, extra luggage, sleeping bags and blankets, and more.  Unlike hard top carriers that are bulky and cumbersome, this Highland Soft Top easily folds down to the size of a shoe box for compact storage.

The straps on the soft car top carrier also proved durable and unrelenting. Some buyers thought that the 4 straps would not be enough to maintain the carrier onto the car through the long drive but they were pleasantly surprised that the straps remained firm and tight. The carrier cleans up quickly because the vinyl material is easy to wash. One consumer commented on the ease of cleaning of the bug splatter with only a simple scrub brush and water.

We found that most consumers of this product praised its durability but some felt slightly let down by the quality of the straps and materials.  About five percent of buyers who purchased this item said that the material didn’t hold well and the straps even left holes.  One buyer found it unsafe and not fit for use.

Buy From Amazon

There were a lot of bonuses of this carrier because of its compact size, quality material and durability. Customers raved over and over again about the large amount of space inside the carrier for storage. Perhaps the best feature that most buyers are raving about on the top carrier is the amazing price for the entire unit.  With the low price of only $60, the Highland 10391 Kar Pak Rainproof Soft Car Top Carrier makes for an excellent value for the money and one that we can highly recommend.

Home | Soft Car Top Carriers

We found amazon.com to have the best prices and shipping policies on all Car Top Carriers including the SportRack Aero 1300. To find out more click here.

SportRack A26395 Features:

• 13 cu. ft. (368 liter) capacity
• Mounts directly to most OEM and aftermarket crossbars with included Quick Release u-bolt mounting kit
• Passenger side opening design includes a lock for secure and easy curbside access
• ABS construction is durable and UV-resistant
• Dimensions: 75″(l) x 23.5″(w) x 16″(h) / 33 lbs. (15 kg), Maximum load of 110 lbs. (50 kg)

SportRack A26395 Reviews:

With over seventy reviews, we found that only one percent had something negative to say about the SportRack A26395 Aero 1300 Roof Box. One customer had a complaint listed that was actually regarding the delivery times and not a negative review of the product. Another consumer was not satisfied because the car top carrier didn’t fit the bars on their SUV so they ended up purchasing new screws.  After getting the Roof Box mounted and filling it up with luggage, the key became stuck.  For the price of 285 dollars, this customer was unhappy by the ineffectiveness of the product.

We saw that over half of consumers that purchased the SportRack A26395 Aero 1300 Roof Box found that their expectations were exceeded in quality and price. They were happy that it came fully assembled minus the brackets that mount to the cross bars. It was easy to install on any crossbar and was able to withstand harsh weather conditions.

The SportRack A26395 Aero 1300 Roof Box also offered excellent wind noise reduction and didn’t feel too heavy to lift or too heavy for the top of the vehicle.  When the Roof Box is placed properly to the back of the vehicle, buyers reported that it didn’t affect the fuel consumption or the gas mileage of the car. The thick molded plastic is of excellent quality and the lock on the box is an added feature that makes the buyer feel safe knowing that not just anyone can access their belongings.

Whether you are taking this product on a family vacation or just need some added space for children’s toys and pet supplies, this item may be an excellent buy that can be used for years. If you have too much to carry and not enough room in your vehicle, this roof box may be the perfect solution to fit comfortably on nearly any car.  Buyers of the SportRack A26395 Aero 1300 Roof Box found it a highly valuable product and well worth the money they spent as it is highly recommended by the majority of users.

Buy From Amazon

With all of the high ratings and great things that reviewers have had to say about the SportRack A26395 Aero 1300 Roof Box, we feel very comfortable recommending this Car Top Carrier as one of our top buys.

Home | Hard Top Carriers

Highland 1039800 Features

• Can be mounted on almost any car carrier
• Weather resistant
• Zipper is covered with  rain protection flaps
• Weighs 5.6 pounds
• Easy to Install

Highland 1039800 Reviews

Considering the price, the product is lightweight and a bit flimsy.  It therefore comes as no surprise that the Highland 1039800 Car Top Cargo Bag has not fared too well in customer review. One customer had complained that the bag did not even last a day, got holed and basically frayed away as their road trip progressed, forcing the family to buy another more expensive Car Top Carrier.

Yet another customer tells us his bad experience with the product, which he says, could be used only once. According to him, the bag tore to shreds at the end of a single trip and had to be disposed.

One customer, who had bought the Highland 1039800 Car Top Bag, regretted his choice as a single downpour left his luggage completely wet. It seems the interior vinyl covering comes apart when wet. Others have reported that the interior lining “flakes off” like “dead skin” as soon as it comes in contact with water. Only one customer claims to have used it in rain and snow and have come out unscathed. Yet another user reports rather dramatically how the bag just disintegrated into “million pieces.” While this characterization may be over exaggeration, the point is that the bag is not water proof and even the “weather resistant”  claim of the company does not stand up to practical scrutiny.

Other customers claim that the bag is good enough for use, but you need to put extra straps to prevent it from flapping around in high wind. However, most customers complained about the poor quality of the material and its inability to withstand even one road trip.

Read More Reviews on Amazon

In overall analysis it can stated quite emphatically that there is a critical limit for reducing the cost of producing a product below which the product will be sub-standard. A Car Top Carrier needs to be rugged to be able to withstand the vagaries of nature. The quality of the material used; the sort of stitching and weatherproofing techniques adopted, adds to the basic cost of producing a good Cargo Bag, which by market survey, points to a price range well above $100. Highland 1039800 Car Top Cargo Bag priced at $45 obviously suffers from  poor material quality and shabby manufacturing process and is one such product that you should avoid at all cost.   Click here to read more reviews

Home | Soft Top Carriers

The Thule 867 stands out as a great product because it can hold from 15 to 17 cubic ft. volume of luggage or items atop a cargo carrier. The carrier bag is like a big flexible suitcase with water resistant fabric and a foam lining inside to protect the items from shocks. We found amazon.com to have the best prices and shipping policies on all Car Top Cargo Carriers including the Thule Tahoe 867 Rooftop Cargo Carrier.  Click here to check it out.

 Thule 867 Tahoe Features

• Tough PVC Coated Nylon material that is water resistant and provides protection against sun, dust and grime
• Robust cargo buckles with straps that are double stitched
• Compartment lined with foam for protecting luggage
• Three sided zipper for ease of opening the bag even when loaded
• Has mesh pockets inside to store smaller items
• Zippers covered with Velcro to bring down wind noise and provide protection
• Padded handles for easy handling atop car carrier
• Separate carrying bag for stowage when not in use
• Life time warranty

Thule 867 Tahoe Reviews

Customers have given a ‘thumbs up’ to Thule 867 Tahoe as the Rooftop Cargo Carrier that delivers on its promise. The reviews talk about ease of attaching the bag to the roof. Users caution that all eight safety pins given along with the bag must be fastened, otherwise, the bag will make noise while driving. Others recount having gone through storms and coming out with their luggage completely dry.

The bag does produce wind drag and the mileage is bound to come down a bit, However, the additional space that can be saved inside the car is well worth the extra bucks spent on more gas used to compensate for the loss of mileage.

Yet other buyers have pointed out that the Cargo Bag is water resistant but not water proof, which means in a really heavy downpour, the luggage may get wet. Some customers have complained that in wet weather the luggage does get wet. However, you have to give credit to the company for it clearly mentions that its product is ‘weather resistant’ and not water proof, so they are not trying to fool you.

Other customers have gone ahead and used the Cargo Bag not only atop their car carriers but also as a large cargo box to stow away extra luggage in their garages to save space in the house. This is a plus point for the product as it has multiple uses.

Though the company claims that the side straps that come with the product are sufficient for tethering the Cargo bag to the top of your carrier, customers have reported that you need to put at least two more restraining straps and cross bars to prevent the bag from shifting around in strong winds and falling off on bumpy roads.

Buy From Amazon

Overall, the Thule 867 Rooftop Cargo Carrier has received good reviews and some average reviews and therefore is worth the money.

Home | Soft Top Carriers

This heavy duty roof top Cargo Bag is just the product that can protect your luggage or your goods from rain, dirt and grime. Amongst Car Top Carriers, Keeper scores because it provides all round protection, leaving no openings through  which rain or dust can enter the carrier once the Cargo bag is secured and
fastened properly over your luggage. It also protects the baggage from the harsh  sun.

We found amazon.com to have the best prices and shipping policies on all Cargo Carriers including the Keeper 07203. To find out more click here.

Keeper 07203 Cargo Carrier Features

• 15 cubic feet volume
• Water proof, dust proof and grime proof as also provides protection
  from the sun
• Flexible material that can accommodate all shapes and sizes of
  items
• Easy to stow away when not in use

The Reviews

The Keeper 07203 has received a majority of rave reviews from customers. Holidaying families vouch for the fact that the Cargo Bag does provide complete protection from rain, dust and grime. One customer even stated that they stored more than 15 cubic feet in their Keeper Cargo Bag atop their Land Cruiser on a long road trip without any problems.

Another user recounted how he drove over 2000 miles across America and faced no problems with the Cargo Bag, it performed as promised. He also confirmed that the product was easy to attach to the roof of his SUV.

The adjusting straps take a little getting used to, but once the correct length has been adjusted, the Cargo Bag works perfectly. Drivers have affirmed that the bag makes no noise even when driving up to 80 mph and thus it does not suffer from the infirmities that other similar products have, of being sensitive to wind speeds.

Families have gone through pouring rain and have found their luggage to be absolutely dry on reaching their destination. The zipper compartment with flaps secured with Velcro ensures 100% waterproofing.

The  flexible 15 cubic feet volume too has been commented upon favorably by users. One family tells the story of driving through harsh Texas weather with two large boxes, three different duffel bags, a host of other smaller funny shaped items, all being stored on the roof top and the Keeper 07203 being able to
accommodate them all. The straps used for securing the Cargo Bag to the car top carrier are robust and do not break though one odd complaint of a strap breaking has also been reported. Most others have, on the contrary, praised the straps and stated that buying extra restraining straps is a waste of money as the ones that come with the bag are good enough.

Buy From Amazon

The material of the cargo bag has been commented upon as being thicker than normal tarpaulin, tough yet flexible enough to be stored compactly in the garage. Almost 250 reviews of this product have been positive with buyers agreeing that the Keeper 07203 Roof Top Cargo Bag was well worth the money spent. Therefore, as a Car Top Carrier, the Keeper 07203 Roof Top Cargo Bag easily aces the line up.

Home | Soft Top Carriers

This car top carrier is perfect for anyone that consistently runs out of passenger space because their cargo is sitting in the seat next to them. It can carry a wide variety of things like luggage, sports equipment, camping gear and a lot more.

The 667ES is quite versatile compared to other car top carriers and can mount on many different factory-installed and aftermarket roof racks. It comes with a rear opening. The box itself measures 55.5 x 18.2 x 35.2 inches and weighs 38 pounds. Thule is so confident about this product that it is backing it with a limited lifetime warranty. The warranty is voided if the purchaser should transfer the product to another person and it will not cover normal wear of the product: this includes accidents, scratches and cosmetic rust.

We found amazon.com to have the best prices and shipping policies on all Cargo Carriers including the Thule Excursion. To find out more click here.

Thule Excursion ES Features

• UV and impact resistant. ABS constructed.
• Locking system is centralized for each closing and opening.
• One key locking system included with 13 cu. ft. capacity.
• Easy to mount and you’re on the road in minutes.
• Can mount to most factory installed and removable racks.

The Reviews

The Thule 667ES Excursion ES Rooftop Cargo Box was reviewed by 24 different customers. It had above average reviews and a lot of positive comments. Out of a possible 5 stars, the 667ES received 4 and a half. Though the product has good reviews overall, it seems that some felt the installation was quite easy while others felt it was a little challenging. The ones that found it easy to install said that it was light weight, yet durable. The directions that come with the package are easy to follow and very thorough. There are also pictures for those that don’t always like to read. The reviewer that found it easy to install had some additional help. Maybe an extra set of hands is all that is needed for installation. Another reviewer, who gave this cargo carrier 5 stars, writes “Bought this for a family vacation and it held up great. It rained while on our way but the items were dry – perfect. We will be using this for many years to come. Easy to install.”

Buy From Amazon

The Thule Excursion car top carrier has many 4 and 5  star ratings and minimal consumer complaints.  Because of this and the extensive research that we have compiled, we feel very comfortable recommending the Thule A667ES “Excursion ES” to anyone looking for a roof top cargo carrier for their vehicle. Look no further than amazon for the best pricing, shipping, and consumer confidence when purchasing this carrier.

Home | Hard Top Carriers

The A90095 offers plenty of space to accommodate, heavy sports gear and extra luggage. Though it offers a lot of space, it doesn’t get in the way of driving. It can carry packages that have a 100 lb capacity. It measures 54 x 19.5 x 39 inches and weighs just 32 pounds when the box is empty. It comes standard with a U-bolt mounting bracket. We found amazon.com to have the best prices on all Car Top Cargo Carriers including the SportRack A90095.  Click Here to check it out.

Features

• Roof box that has 18 cubic feet capacity.
• Can be mounted on many aftermarket and OEM crossbars. Comes with a u-bolt mounting kit.
• Box needs to be assembled.
• Simple design that allows side opening. It also includes a lock for easy and secure curbside access.
• Measures 54 x 39 x 19.5 inches. It weighs 32 pounds when empty and has a maximum load of 100 pounds.

The Reviews

The SportRack A90095 Explorer Roof Box was reviewed by 60 different people at the time of this post. The SportRack A90095 received, on average, 4 out of 5 possible stars. An extensive review of the comments did show a lot of good positive comments overall. Many liked the fact that your gear is kept safe within the cargo box. One family put it to the test immediately after ordering the product. They had driven through a major snow storm. Tons of cars had to stop because of the harsh conditions, but they just trekked on. When they reached their destination, there was not a drop of water inside.

Reviewers liked that it is very spacious. One person had said they were able to store 2 pieces of luggage that were easily over 20 inches each with a small duffle bag. It was able to accommodate everything quite nicely.

Many liked the price for the large amount of space that is available in this carrier. Other cargo boxes that have the same product offering sells at two or even three times the price of this model. Don’t let the low price fool you. This is a great alternative. When the product arrives, it does look a little flimsy, but when it is attached to the crossbars, you soon see that it is a good quality product.

Some people have forgotten this carrier was even attached to the vehicle because it does not make any noises, even though you encounter wind. This will definitely solve some of the storage problems you currently face, especially if you have a family to think about.

Buy From Amazon

With the many 4  star ratings for the Sportrack A90095 Explorer Car Top Cargo Carrier and minimal compaints about this product, we feel very comfortable recommending the Sportrack A90095 to anyone looking for a roof top cargo carrier for their vehicle.

Home | Hard Top Carriers

The SportRack A90275 offers 18 cu. ft. of space and plenty of room for boots, tents, golf bags, luggage and more. This car top cargo carrier has a rear-opening that can be mounted onto just about any rooftop crossbar. To reduce attachment headaches, it comes with a U-bolt mounting bracket. This is a durable box that can withstand a fair amount of abuse. It clings on while you make your way through rough terrain, bad weather conditions, swipes from branches and more.

The SportRack A90275 measures 38 x 19 x 63 and includes a single lock mechanism that is strategically placed in the rear. It can accommodate a maximum capacity load  of 110 pounds. We found amazon.com to have the best prices on all Car Top Carriers including the SportRack A90275 Aero XL Roof Box.  Click Here to check it out.

SportRack Features

• Roof box that can mount directly to almost any aftermarket and OEM crossbars.
• The U-bolt that comes with the kit is Quick Releasing.
• 18 cubic feet capacity.
• Provides easy access because of its rear-opening design and includes a lock for security.
• UV resistant and durable ABS construction.
• Measures 63 x 38 x 38 inches and has a maximum load capacity of 110 pounds (50kg).
• ABS plastic shell that is easy to install.

SportRack Reviews

The Sportrack A90275 Aero XL Roof Box has been reviewed by almost 100 different customers. Overall the reviews were very positive. At the time of this review, the product has received on average 4 and a half stars out of a possible 5. Reviewers liked that it was very easy to mount on their cross bar. It “feels sturdy” was one reviewers comment. No rattling or wind noise is heard inside your vehicle. Most people report this at speeds higher than 65 MPH. There was also very positive comments on this car top cargo carrier about keeping the inside contents completely dry, even through torrential storms. One reviewer writes, “On the way to my destination, I hit a severe storm on the freeway and drove through 50+ mph winds and torrential downpours. I arrived and all contents were dry and the rack did not shift. As far as gas mileage, the same reviewer wrote, “I averaged 23 mpg at 70 mph with my 4.0L van. This is approximately what I achieve without the SportRack.” So, as you can see, there are many positive reviews on this cartop cargo carrier including durability, wind noise, weather resistance, and gas mileage.

Buy From Amazon

With all the 4 and 5 star ratings for the SportRack A90275 Aero XL Roof Box and wonderful things people have to say about this product, we feel very comfortable recommending the this product to anyone looking for a rooftop cargo carrier for their vehicle.

Home | Hard Top Carriers